I was on the oldest forum from the start because I really believe we were going to be the people's band. I was a person, not some hoity-toity artiste or whatever. I could create and shape and express music on one hand and have a beer with anyone. Mostly, I just like to chat and take part. The forum was a good place for that.
It's no secret that the forum became a magical place for a lot of people. I'm a member of quite a few and there was definitely something different about it. People were real, and although there were the natural differences, it made for interesting reads.
For anyone else that's part of forums, you know, at some point, the phenomenon of "forum world war" happens. A mass shitstorm of hate and anger. I believe I experienced one of the worst of these on the XTC forum as well as the UK Hipforum coming in a close second. Both survived and thrived eventually, but there were some dark days. And they're both still there.
By comparison, the spree board's was tame. very tame. Also, as bc has said, it was actually perpetrated by a (then) band member. That's a bit different I have to say. But even though the whole demeanor of the board was negative at the time, there were signs of it turning towards the end. Suddenly other band members were posting (who had been lurking the whole time, btw, and for reasons I still find suspect), and then suddenly, it seemed as if they were coming back to the people. They were interacting with people instead of PETA (really, wtf was that about?)
And then they pulled it. Idiots. When it's all said and done, that will be one of the biggest points of failure; when adversity strikes, you take your toys and go home. Nevermind that it would eventually end and a new day would dawn.
I'll stop the philosophy and history lesson. I missed a lot apparently what went on in my nighttime here, but I'll say this, there's only one person who can pull that forum, and he's a forker too

And I'll go back to my beer and the few spree songs i enjoy...